When remodeling your kitchen or designing a new one, the countertop decision is by far the most overwhelming.
Choosing which countertop material is right for you is the most significant decisions you’ll make.
Your countertops are not only used as functional spaces, they are a very important part of the design of your space.
Therefore, its very important to know all the different features of the materials you are comparing for your countertops.
In this article, I will answer the question “porcelain vs marble countertops: Which is better”
The short and instant answer is :
If you are looking for a very durable countertop with no to minimal maintenance, then Porcelain is better.
On the flip side, if you want the real deal, durability, the epitome of luxury and are open to do regular maintenance, then marble is better.
This post is about Porcelain vs Marble countertops
Now let’s discuss everything in detail. Here is what I will cover :
- What is Porcelain & How are porcelain countertops manufactured ?
- What is Marble and How are Marble slabs made ?
- Porcelain Countertops: Pros and Cons
- Marble Countertops: Pros and Cons
- Comparing Porcelain vs Marble
- Scratch Resistance
- Heat Resistance
- How to Choose between the two ?
What is Porcelain & How are porcelain countertops manufactured ?
- Porcelain is a man-made product.
- Porcelain is a ceramic material that’s baked at extremely high temperatures to ensure hardness and durability.
- Porcelain tiles and ceramic tiles have been used for walls and flooring for decades.
- To manufacture porcelain, a mixture of raw materials like natural clay, feldspar , mineral oxides and kaolin is used.
- This mixture is also known as China Clay.
- The mixture is wet-milled to a liquid slurry.
- This slurry is then dried and formed into large porcelain slabs.
What is Marble and How are Marble slabs made ?
- Marble is a natural stone product.
- It is a metamorphic rock, primarily composed of calcium carbonate.
- It forms when limestone is subjected to high temperatures and pressures over a long period, causing a crystalline structure.
- Marble is extracted from quarries using large machines in the form of blocks.
- The blocks are then sliced into slabs at the factories.
- It’s popular for its elegant, veiny patterns, and comes in a variety of shades from white to black.
Porcelain Countertops: Pros and Cons
Pros of Porcelain kitchen countertops:
Porcelain slab countertops are very durable.
These countertops are resistant to scratches, cracks, heat, and UV rays, making them perfect for both indoor and outdoor applications.
They are one of the popular countertop materials for outdoor kitchens.
Since the porcelain material is a manufactured material, nothing happens to it in direct sunlight.
Porcelain bathroom countertops are a better option than natural marble.
The water resistance feature of porcelain makes it an ideal choice for any area indoor or outdoor.
One of the most important factors that people like is that it comes in a variety of colors and patterns.
You can find porcelain slabs that look like natural stone countertops.
They are so many options in porcelain countertops that have the look of marble, wood look, onyx look and even concrete look.
This makes a lot of people very happy.
Porcelain countertops are very low maintenance.
They don’t require sealing like natural stone countertops.
Since they are non-porous in nature, the countertop surface is resistant to staining.
Larger Slabs :
Porcelain slabs are manufactured in larger sizes.
This is very helpful when the kitchen renovation has large islands.
When covering the large area, there are fewer seams.
Porcelain countertops are an excellent choice for outdoor kitchens.
Porcelain is resistant to sunlight and UV rays.
Porcelain is heat resistant. You can put hot pans directly on the marble look porcelain.
Cons of Porcelain Countertops:
Not The Real Deal:
While we have so many beautiful options, porcelain mimics marble patterns. It’s not the real deal. The natural patterns that marble gets in mother nature are all so unique.
Chips & Cracks:
Porcelain can chip or crack with high impact. The not so great part is that it can not be repaired.
Porcelain slabs are generally thinner than marble.
The standard thicknesses are typically around 6mm (approximately 1/4 inch) and 12mm (approximately 1/2 inch).
Due to its thinner nature, porcelain offers fewer edge choices.
Mitered edge is commonly done with porcelain to give an illusion of a thicker countertop surface.
I like this video on Porcelain Countertops by H S Design Studio
Marble Countertops: Pros and Cons
Pros of Marble Countertops
Marble screams luxury.
It is a natural stone with beautiful veining and a range of colors, making each slab unique.
It adds a classic, timeless appeal to any kitchen or bathroom.
The unique patterns and veining makes is one of the most popular options for countertops.
Marble, while robust, is more susceptible to scratches and staining.
However, with proper care and maintenance, it can last for generations.
Marble is available in 2cm and 3cm thickness. This gives an opportunity to choose more options for edge profiles.
Cons of Marble Countertops
Marble is a porous natural product. It requires regular sealing to maintain it.
It is also a soft material and prone to scratching.
I will not recommend using ceramic knives or any other knives directly on the marble surface.
Marble is not water resistant.
When using marble tiles in the bathroom, you should take proper care to seal then periodically.
If marble tile or countertop are not sealed regularly, it will start to etch. You will see shaded, foggy areas develop on the surface.
Marble can not be used for outdoor applications.
Chips & Cracks:
Marble can chip or crack with high impact. Unlike porcelain, this can be repaired.
Marble is not heat resistant. You need to use hot pads when using hot pots .
Porcelain Countertops cost Versus Marble
Porcelain countertops on average cost less and is a more affordable option than marble when it comes to material cost.
If you talk about installation costs, porcelain can cost as much as marble sometimes.
It usually depends on the complexity of design.
Comparing Porcelain vs Marble
Here is a simple table showing you comparison between porcelain and marble countertops.
How to Choose between the two ?
I think it really comes down to personal preference after you take into consideration the following factors:
If budget is a concern, porcelain might be the more economical choice.
However, if you’re willing to splurge for a high-end look, marble could be the better option.
Consider your lifestyle. If you’re someone who uses their kitchen heavily and doesn’t want to worry about maintenance, porcelain may be the better option.
For those who don’t mind a little extra care for the sake of beauty, marble could be the way to go.
I will tell you that I have Calacatta Macchia Vecchia marble in my kitchen.
I don’t mind taking extra care as I wanted the real deal. I enjoy them everyday.
I hope you are now ready to decide which is a better choice for you.
Is porcelain more durable than marble?
Yes, porcelain is generally more durable and resistant to stains, scratches, and heat compared to marble.
Is marble more expensive than porcelain?
Typically, marble is more expensive due to its luxurious and high-end appeal. However, costs can vary depending on the type of marble and where it’s sourced.
Can porcelain mimic the look of marble?
Yes, porcelain can mimic the look of other materials, including marble. However, it’s worth noting that it won’t perfectly replicate the unique veining and natural beauty of genuine marble.
Which is better for a busy kitchen, porcelain or marble?
For a busy kitchen, porcelain might be a better choice due to its durability and low maintenance needs.
However, if you’re willing to put in the effort to maintain marble’s beauty, and if budget is not a concern, marble will give you the high-end, luxurious feel to your kitchen.
Is porcelain cheaper than marble
Yes, Porcelain is generally cheaper than marble.
This post was about Porcelain vs Marble countertops
You May Like These: