Hey there! So you’re deciding between Corian and Granite for your new countertops ?
Both of these options are top-notch and popular countertop materials, when you think about durability, looks, and versatility.
But here’s the thing, each has its own special benefits and features that might suit different tastes or needs.
In this article “Corian solid surface Vs Granite”, I will break down the costs and details for both.
By the time you are done reading you’ll have everything you need to make the best choice for your upcoming kitchen remodel or home makeover.
Let’s get started…..
This post is about Corian Vs Granite
JUMP TO:
Understanding Corian & Granite
What is Corian Solid Surface?
Corian is a brand of solid surface countertops, but it’s often used to describe solid surface countertops made of natural minerals, acrylic, and pigments.
Picture the flexibility of plastic with a touch of natural beauty!
DuPont came up with it back in 1967.
Imagine taking natural minerals from something called bauxite ore and blending it with an acrylic polymer.
The outcome? Corian.
The whole idea was to get a surface that’s super easy to clean, won’t soak up any spills, and if by chance it gets scratched or damaged, it can be fixed up without much fuss.
That’s your Corian countertops.
What is Granite ?
Granite is Mother Nature’s artwork.
It’s an igneous rock formed from cooled and solidified magma, boasting unique patterns and colors with every slab.
We’re talking about a rock that’s been around since, well, forever!
This rock’s been a favorite for builders and artists for thousands of years.
I mean, it’s hardy and every piece looks unique — like a natural piece of art.
When folks want to get their hands on granite, they head to quarries, chiseling out massive blocks of the stone.
These blocks? They’re sliced into shiny slabs, all set for someone’s kitchen or bathroom.
Each slice is its own masterpiece, full of colors and patterns only Mother Nature could whip up.
So there you have it: Corian’s the sleek, modern player in the game, while granite’s the classic, timeless choice.
It really comes down to whether you’re feeling the contemporary vibe of Corian or the ageless charm of granite
Physical Characteristics of Corian & Granite
Corian Solid Surface Material
Corian Solid Surfaces:
Starting with Corian, it’s a blend of acrylic polymer resins and natural minerals.
Now, in simpler terms, think of it like a high-tech plastic mixed with some earthy stuff.
Because of this blend, Corian has a pretty smooth and consistent texture.
Touching its surface, you’ll feel something uniform without any natural imperfections.
In terms of weight, Corian is lighter than granite, but don’t mistake that for weakness; it’s still pretty sturdy.
Its consistency?
Totally even. solid-surface countertop can do no veins, no sudden color changes, just a uniform look all over.
Granite Stone Countertops:
Granite, as I said before is a natural material.
It’s an igneous rock, so it’s basically formed from magma that cooled down over a gazillion years.
Composition-wise, it’s made up of minerals like quartz, feldspar, and mica.
When you run your hand across a granite countertop, you’ll feel those natural textures – it’s a bit grainy and every piece is unique.
In terms of weight, granite’s definitely on the heavier side, given it’s a solid chunk of rock.
And its consistency? Totally unpredictable! You could have veins here, specks there, and maybe swirls somewhere else.
Every slab tells a different story.
Weight of Corian vs Granite Countertop Surfaces
Alright, Let’s talk weight differences.
when it comes to weight, Corian and granite are pretty different, given their distinct compositions.
Let’s break it down.
Corian:
Corian, being a combination of acrylic polymer and natural minerals, is lighter than granite.
Typically, Corian weighs around 2.5 to 3 pounds per square foot for a half-inch thick sheet.
This lighter weight can make it a tad easier to handle and install, especially in larger pieces.
But, of course, as the thickness increases, so does the weight.
Granite:
Granite, being a dense, natural rock, is noticeably heavier.
On average, a granite slab of about 3/4-inch (2 centimeters) thick can weigh about 12-13 pounds per square foot.
If you’re going for a thicker slab, which is around 1 1/4-inch (or 3 centimeters), it can weigh somewhere around 18-20 pounds per square foot.
Its weight is something to consider, especially when planning for transportation, handling, and support during installation.
Aesthetic Differences
Range of Colors, Patterns, and Finishes:
Corian:
Corian offers a lot of different colors, from solid colors to ones that mimic the look of natural stone or even concrete.
Because it’s a manufactured product, it can be produced in nearly any shade or pattern, allowing homeowners a wide range of design choices for kitchen countertops.
The finishes available for Corian range from matte to glossy.
Since Corian is non-porous and homogeneous throughout, its appearance is very consistent throughout its thickness.
You can achieve seamless blending with sinks and backsplashes.
Granite:
Granite’s beauty lies in its natural variety.
Each slab is a one-of-a-kind piece with its unique pattern, which means no two granite countertops are ever identical.
The range of colors isn’t as vast as Corian, but granite being a natural product does offer a rich selection of earthy tones, from deep blacks and grays to radiant reds, blues, and even greens.
The natural veins, specks, and swirls add depth and character to the stone.
Finishes for granite can vary from polished (shiny) to honed (matte) and even leathered for a textured feel.
Uniqueness vs. Uniformity:
Granite stands out for its organic, unpredictable patterns.
It can become a statement piece in a space due to its distinct appearance.
Corian, on the other hand, is known for its uniformity.
While you can choose patterns that look like natural stone, they will be consistent throughout the material.
Design Flexibility and Settings:
Corian:
Because of its wide range of colors and ability to be shaped, Corian offers significant design flexibility.
It can be thermoformed into various shapes and designs, making it ideal for custom work.
Corian’s versatility allows it to fit seamlessly into both contemporary and traditional settings.
The ability to create integrated sinks and other custom features makes it particularly appealing for sleek, modern designs.
Granite:
Granite lends itself more to settings where natural beauty is highlighted.
Its timeless appeal makes it a favorite for traditional spaces, but its unique patterns can also make it a centerpiece in contemporary designs.
Granite offers a touch of luxury and a connection to nature, which can elevate any design setting.
In conclusion, the choice between Corian and granite will largely depend on the aesthetic you’re aiming for.
Want something sleek, customizable, and modern? Corian might be your pick.
Looking for natural beauty, richness, and a touch of luxury? Granite could be the way to go.
Either way, both materials bring a unique charm to spaces.
Comparing Durability & Longevity
Durability & Wear and Tear:
Corian:
Corian is pretty durable material, but it isn’t as hard as granite.
This means it can be susceptible to scratches, especially from sharp objects.
On the upside, because it’s a solid surface material, any minor scratches or damages can often be buffed out.
It’s non-porous, which makes it resistant to most stains, but it’s not as heat resistant as granite.
So, placing hot pots or pans directly on a Corian countertop is not recommended.
Granite:
Granite is a rockstar when it comes to toughness.
It’s one of the hardest natural stones, which makes it resistant to scratches.
You can even cut directly on it, though it might dull your knives.
As for heat, granite surfaces can take it!
You can set a hot pot right onto the surface without damage.
However, since granite is porous, if it’s not sealed properly, it can stain.
So, spills, especially oils or wines, should be wiped up quickly.
Scratch, Heat, and Stain Resistance:
Corian Surfaces:
- Scratch Resistance: Moderate. Avoid cutting directly on it.
- Heat Resistance: Moderate. Use trivets or pads for hot items. Because of synthetic materials like polyester resins it can not handle excessive heat.
- Stain Resistance: High. Its non-porous surface repels most stains.
Granite Surfaces:
- Scratch Resistance: High. Tough against scratches, but don’t dull your knives.
- Heat Resistance: High. It can handle extreme heat very well.
- Stain Resistance: Moderately stain resistant. Needs sealing to prevent stains.
Expected Lifespan with Proper Care:
Corian:
With proper care, a Corian countertop can last several decades. Ensure you avoid direct heat exposure and use cutting boards to prolong its life.
Granite:
Granite can last a lifetime!
With regular sealing (typically once a year or as needed) and proper care, it’s not uncommon for granite countertops to remain in great condition for 50 years or more.
In conclusion, while both materials are durable and are great countertop options , they have their strengths and weaknesses.
Your choice might hinge on your kitchen habits, whether you’re the type to occasionally place a hot pan on the counter, or if you’re prone to spilling.
Either way, with a little love and care, both surfaces can serve you well for years to come.
Comparing Maintenance & Care
Corian:
Cleaning & Daily Care: For everyday cleaning, use a damp cloth or sponge and a mild soap or detergent.
Avoid window cleaners as they can leave a waxy build-up.
Precautions:
- Avoid placing hot pans or pots directly on Corian counters, use trivets or heat pads. High heat can cause permanent damage.
- Sharp objects can scratch the surface, so always use a cutting board.
Repairing Damages:
- Minor Damages: Small scratches or burns can often be buffed out using a mild abrasive cleaner or a Scotch-Brite pad.
- Major Damages: Deep cuts or scorches might require professional refinishing. Fortunately, the solid and consistent nature of Corian means repairs can blend seamlessly.
Granite:
Cleaning & Daily Care: Wipe the surface with warm water and a few drops of dish soap using a soft cloth or sponge. For a deeper clean or to shine it up, you can use cleaners specifically designed for granite.
Precautions:
- Granite is strong, but it’s still a good idea to use cutting boards to protect both the stone and your knives.
- Although it’s heat resistant, consistent direct heat could cause damage over time, so using trivets or heat pads is a good practice.
- Seal your granite periodically (often annually) to keep it stain-resistant.
Repairing Damages:
- Minor Damages: Small scratches or etches can often be polished out, but it’s best to let professionals handle it to ensure the shine matches the rest of the countertop.
- Major Damages: Deep chips or cracks will typically need a professional repair. They might fill it with a color-matched epoxy or resin.
Comparing Cost & Installation
Let’s discuss the price difference and logistical aspects of choosing Corian or slab of granite.
Cost & Installation:
Corian:
Price Range:
Corian prices generally falls into the mid-range for countertop materials.
Prices can vary, but you might expect to pay between $40 to $80 per square feet, including installation.
Factors such as color, finish, and the complexity of the design can affect the cost.
Factors Influencing Cost:
The main factors effecting Corian costs include brand, color, finish, and any custom designs or features like integrated sinks.
Installation Challenges:
Corian can be more forgiving during installation due to its flexibility. It’s lighter than granite, making it somewhat easier to handle.
Joints can be made almost invisible, which is a plus for a seamless look. However, because it’s malleable, ensuring a level installation is crucial.
Granite:
Price Range:
The granite costs can vary widely based on its rarity and quality.
On average, prices might range from $50 to $200 per square foot, including installation.
Exotic granites with rare colors or patterns can fetch a premium.
Various Factors Influencing Cost:
Rarity of the granite, the country of origin, color, and the finish (polished, honed, leathered) play significant roles in determining the price.
Additionally, the cost can be influenced by the thickness of the slab and any custom fabrication like edge designs.
Installation Challenges:
Granite is heavy, which can make transportation and installation more challenging.
It requires multiple people to install and might need additional support structures, especially for larger overhangs.
The seams in granite are more noticeable than in Corian, so alignment and matching are essential.
Also, granite is brittle (not crack resistance) so care must be taken to avoid chipping or cracking during installation.
You should always double check the pricing in your area.
Environmental considerations for each material
I have listed the differences in the following table.
Popular Misconceptions
Here are the Myths and Facts Listed for both:
Corian solid surface countertop materials offers a modern, consistent look, and while durable, it’s more sensitive to heat and scratches than granite.
However, it’s easier to install and maintain.
Granite showcases a unique, natural beauty and is exceptionally durable, especially against heat.
Yet, it requires periodic sealing and can be heavier to handle during installation.
Both materials are solid choices, with Corian leaning more towards contemporary designs and granite offering a timeless appeal.
Your decision for the right countertops should be based on aesthetic preferences, maintenance comfort, and budget.
FAQs
Is Corian cheaper than granite?
Generally, Corian can be more affordable, but prices vary based on specifics.
Does granite increase home resale value more than Corian?
Often, yes. Granite is frequently seen as a luxury material.
Can Corian resist knife cuts?
It’s more susceptible to scratches than granite, so always use a cutting board.
Does granite fade over time?
No, its color remains consistent, especially if it’s well-maintained.
Which is more eco-friendly, Corian or granite?
Corian, being man-made, has a more controlled production process, while granite mining can be more invasive to the environment.
Can Corian and granite be used outdoors?
While granite fares well outdoors, Corian’s color may fade with prolonged UV exposure.
How do both materials react to direct heat?
Granite can withstand high temperatures. Corian, however, might warp or discolor with direct heat.
What are the colors options available in Corian solid surface countertops ?
Corian is available in variety of options. You can find it in look of marble, wood countertops and even in the look of granite.
Are all granite countertops pure granite countertops ?
While granite slabs are natural stone material, some countertops might be “granite composite” – a mix of granite and resin. Consumers should verify what they’re getting.
What other types of countertops that are available to compare?
There are quite a few viable alternative options:
Quartz countertops, Stainless steel countertops, Laminate countertops and quartzite countertops.
This post was about Corian Vs Granite
Do Quartz countertops Stain: A How to care Guide
Best Guide for Choosing 2cm Vs 3cm Countertop Thickness
Honed Granite Vs Polished: What’s the Difference
Leave a Reply